Jeffries’ Past Jerusalem Comments Complicate House Speaker Bid

A resurfaced 2020 video of Hakeem Jeffries calling Jerusalem a "sixth borough" has emerged as the House leader navigates shifting party views on Israel.
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries finds himself navigating a complex internal divide as he prepares for the upcoming House speaker election, following the resurfacing of comments from 2020 in which he labeled Jerusalem as New York City’s “sixth borough.”
The remarks, made during a speech at an American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) event more than six years ago, were part of an address in which the New York Democrat articulated his support for Israel. Recalling a conversation about his travel, Jeffries stated, “I’m from New York City — and back home in New York City, we consider Jerusalem to be the 6th Borough. And so, I’m just trying to catch up with my constituents.”
During the same address, Jeffries characterized the geopolitical climate surrounding Israel as a “tough neighborhood,” referencing concerns regarding the Sinai, Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria, and Iran.
These resurfaced comments, which recently went viral, arrive at a pivotal moment for Jeffries. Having recently secured his party’s nomination for speaker through a secret-ballot vote—where he received 251 votes in favor and 11 against—he now faces the task of managing a Democratic caucus that is increasingly fractured on the issue of U.S.-Israel policy. While Jeffries secured his nomination, the path to the Speakership in January requires a simple majority of the 435-member House, leaving him to address growing pressure from the progressive wing of his party.
The current political environment within the Democratic caucus contrasts sharply with the sentiments Jeffries expressed in 2020. At least eight members slated to serve in the 120th Congress maintain ties to the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), an organization that has advocated for the cessation of military and economic aid to Israel. Furthermore, Representatives-elect Brad Lander and Scott Wiener have publicly called for a full embargo of the country.
Jeffries’ approach to the U.S.-Israel relationship has undergone changes since the conflict with Hamas began in October 2023. In a July 2026 letter to his colleagues, Jeffries acknowledged the need for a “meaningful change in direction” regarding security arrangements. He noted that Israel possesses an advanced economy capable of funding its own weapons, arguing that future agreements should align with standards applied to other Western allies and adhere strictly to U.S. human rights laws.
Despite calls from the party’s left flank for more drastic measures, Jeffries has rejected proposals for a complete cutoff of aid. In his letter, he explicitly condemned efforts by Rep. Thomas Massie to end assistance, supporting the inclusion of a $3.3 billion military aid package in the 2027 State Department appropriations bill. While acknowledging that the conflict has prompted concerns over civilian casualties, Jeffries maintains that the American commitment to Israel as a Jewish and democratic state “must remain ironclad.”