Australia News

South Australian Health Network Abandons Birthing Model Trial

A month-long birthing-service trial in South Australia's Mid North has been halted following clinician opposition and significant community pushback.

The Yorke and Northern Local Health Network (YNLHN) has discontinued a new birthing-service model in South Australia’s Mid North after only one month of a planned six-month trial. The decision comes following significant community opposition and a refusal by local clinicians to participate in the new arrangement.

The trial, which began on October 12, utilized a “one-team, one-site” model that saw services alternate between hospitals in Jamestown and Crystal Brook. The YNLHN governing board implemented the trial to address ongoing workforce shortages and to meet state rostering requirements. According to YNLHN board chair John Voumard, the two hospitals were the only sites in the state currently failing to meet the requirement of having five doctors per site for every rostered shift, 365 days a year.

Local general practitioners, however, raised “urgent concern” when the trial commenced, arguing that the model hindered their ability to provide maternity and emergency on-call services simultaneously and created unnecessary complications in clinical handovers. Bernadette Mulholland, chief industrial officer of the South Australian Salaried Medical Officers Association (SASMOA), stated that local practitioners disagreed with the network’s “rostering position” and that the rosters were deemed “unsustainable.” Following the refusal of clinicians to participate, the network opted to end the trial.

The cancellation follows a period of intense community advocacy. A petition calling for an inquiry into the YNLHN, which gathered nearly 12,000 signatures, is scheduled to be tabled in parliament next week. Geoff Brock, the Member for Stuart, stated that the move to end the trial reflected “common sense” and highlighted a “lack of confidence” from the community regarding the network board’s operation and communication.

While acknowledging that communication with the public could have been improved, Mr. Voumard maintained that broader community concerns were based on “misinformation.” He expressed regret that the community was subjected to anxiety, but emphasized that the initial decision to implement the trial was a matter of adhering to SA Health policy rather than a subject for community consultation.

Both hospitals will continue to offer birthing services, provided they meet the established rostering requirements. The YNLHN warned that until the region sees an influx of doctors and midwives, the system remains vulnerable to staffing gaps, and there will continue to be a possibility of short-notice diversions for expectant mothers.

Back to top button