Critics Divided as Hunger Games Prequel ‘Sunrise On The Reaping’ Hits Theaters

The latest expansion of the Hunger Games cinematic universe has arrived in theaters, prompting a stark divide among critics regarding the future of the long-running franchise. Set a quarter-century before the events of the original 2012 film, the new prequel, “Sunrise On The Reaping,” explores the backstory of the eventual mentor Haymitch Abernathy, portrayed in this installment by Joseph Zada. Woody Harrelson, who played the character in the earlier films, serves as the spiritual predecessor to this younger iteration.
Directed by Francis Lawrence, the film features an ensemble cast that includes Elle Fanning as Effie Trinket, Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman, Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee, and Ralph Fiennes as Coriolanus Snow. The cast is rounded out by Mckenna Grace, Billy Porter, and Glenn Close. Despite the star power, early critical reactions to the 158-minute feature have ranged from high praise for its scale to sharp dismissal of its narrative necessity.
Proponents of the film have lauded its production quality and thematic relevance. In a four-star review, Time Out described the film as “far stronger than so many fished-from-the-bin franchise revivals,” praising the visual assurance provided by Lawrence, despite noting some issues with CGI in the arena. Similarly, the Associated Press labeled it a “surprisingly strong” outing that celebrates resistance to authoritarianism, suggesting the narrative remains timely for 2026 audiences. Little White Lies also offered a positive assessment, calling the work a “thrilling return to form” and noting that with Zada in the lead, the story was well worth the wait.
Radio Times, which also awarded the film four stars, characterized it as a “mighty 158-minute spectacle,” acknowledging that while it suffers from a “dragging middle” and a “rushed finale,” the performances are sufficient to carry the story. TheWrap suggested the prequel avoids the pitfalls of its predecessor, “The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes,” by maintaining energy until the end, concluding that when the dust settles, the film might be one of the best in the franchise.
Conversely, other reviewers found the experience tedious and redundant. The Guardian, which gave the film one star, criticized it as “utterly exhausted, unbearably extended and now surreally boring,” arguing it exists solely to generate revenue from the fanbase. IndieWire described it as a “dreary slog” that mistakes darkness and trauma for profundity. Deadline echoed this sentiment, noting that the franchise feels “tired” and lacks a sense of peril, comparing the stakes to a “High School Musical moment.”
Other critics offered a more mixed assessment. The AV Club graded the film a B-, noting that while Zada and Grace are appealing, the film cannot match the “surprising mixture of folk musical and wartime-espionage noir” found in previous entries. The Los Angeles Times found the central premise “pretty dull” onscreen, noting that the emotional payoff does not land until the final minutes. The New York review pointed out that because the fates of returning characters are already established, the film often feels like a “foregone conclusion.”
As the film begins its theatrical run, the fundamental question remains: does the franchise have a compelling reason to continue? For some, “Sunrise On The Reaping” is a capable, if flawed, spectacle; for others, it is a sign that the series has reached its limit.