California Woman Settles Dispute Over House Built on Her Hawaii Lot

A years-long legal dispute regarding a $500,000 house mistakenly built on a privately owned acre of land in Hawaii has ended, with court records indicating that a confidential settlement was reached in May 2025.
The controversy began in the Hawaiian Paradise Park subdivision in the Puna district of Hawaii’s Big Island. Annaleine “Anne” Reynolds, a California resident, had purchased the vacant lot at a county tax auction in 2018 for approximately $22,500. Reynolds remained in California during the Covid-19 pandemic and was unaware that construction had occurred on her property until 2023, when a real estate broker contacted her to report that the house had been sold.

The home was one of about a dozen residences commissioned by the Keaau Development Partnership. Following the error, the developer sued Reynolds, the construction firm PJ’s Construction, the project architect, and other associated parties. According to court filings, the developer attempted to resolve the issue by offering to swap Reynolds’ land for an adjacent plot of similar value, an offer she rejected.
Reynolds filed a counterclaim, maintaining that she had no knowledge of or involvement in the unauthorized construction. Her attorney, James DiPasquale, argued that accepting a land swap would establish a dangerous precedent, asserting, “It would set a dangerous precedent, if you could go on to someone else’s land, build anything you want, and then sue that individual for the value of it.”

Legal representatives for the developer, Peter Olson, countered that his client believed Reynolds was attempting to exploit the mistake for financial gain, suggesting that many lots in the subdivision share similar layouts and dimensions. Simultaneously, disputes arose between the companies involved in the project. DiPasquale noted that there was “a lot of fingers being pointed between the developer and the contractor and some subs.” An attorney for PJ’s Construction stated that the Keaau Development Partnership had declined to pay for professional land surveyors, opting instead to estimate property lines using telephone poles.
In June 2024, a Hawaii County judge ruled in favor of Reynolds, dismissing the developer’s lawsuit and rejecting claims that her property title was invalid. The court found that the developer and contractor had assumed the risk by failing to conduct a survey and initially ordered that the house be removed. While the judge denied a subsequent request from Reynolds to have the land restored to its original state with native plants, the legal conflict continued until the confidential agreement was finalized in May 2025.