Opinion & Analysis

Mandatory Voting Could Address Declining Civic Participation in America

As American election cycles conclude, the stark reality of non-participation remains a persistent feature of the democratic process. Despite significant attention surrounding recent high-profile contests, tens of millions of eligible citizens do not cast ballots. Data from the 2024 presidential election indicates that 89 million eligible voters did not participate—a figure that, if viewed as a candidate, would have outpaced the totals secured by either Donald Trump or Kamala Harris.

While voter turnout in recent midterm elections has seen improvements compared to historical lows, participation remains fragmented. In the most recent midterms, less than 50% of eligible voters cast ballots. This participation gap is particularly pronounced among younger demographics; although turnout for voters aged 18 to 29 saw a relative increase, their 12% share of the total electorate remained the lowest among all age groups. Critics of the current voluntary system, such as Ben Aviles, argue that this lack of broad engagement forces candidates to prioritize the agendas of consistent, high-propensity voters while neglecting the interests of those less likely to participate.

image

Miles Rapoport, executive director of 100% Democracy, suggests that a voluntary system allows politicians to effectively ignore significant portions of the electorate. According to Rapoport, programs that serve non-voting populations, such as funding for children’s initiatives like Head Start, often face greater budgetary uncertainty than programs serving high-turnout demographics like seniors. To remedy this, Rapoport advocates for universal voting, a policy he describes as the only mechanism to ensure the electorate reflects the population as a whole. He proposes enforcing participation through a modest fine, such as $20.

Alternative strategies include incentivizing civic participation rather than relying solely on penalties. Aviles proposes using tax breaks or direct payments to reward civic activity, likening the time investment of voting to jury duty. Anthony Fowler, a professor at the University of Chicago’s Harris School of Public Policy, notes that from a theoretical standpoint, both positive incentives and penalties serve as valid tools for increasing participation. Fowler cites the historical examples of Australia and Costa Rica, where mandatory voting policies have been used to secure higher turnout rates.

image

Despite these precedents, implementing such a system in the United States faces significant practical and constitutional questions. While both Rapoport and Fowler view mandatory voting as constitutionally permissible, they agree that federal implementation is unlikely. Instead, they suggest that individual states could pilot universal voting systems, potentially authorizing municipalities or counties to test the model with added incentives. As the conversation shifts toward reform, supporters point to the expansion of same-day voter registration—which grew from seven states in 2006 to 24 states and Washington, D.C. today—as evidence that electoral systems can undergo significant, once-considered outlandish, changes.

Mason Clark

Mason Clark writes about culture, communities, education, arts, and social change. His coverage explores the traditions, ideas, and public conversations shaping society, with an emphasis on thoughtful context and the experiences of diverse communities.
Back to top button