Judge Could Set New Trial Date for Lindsay Clancy

A judge could set a new trial date as soon as Monday for Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts woman whose first trial for the deaths of her three young children ended with a deadlocked jury.
Prosecutors have not yet said whether they plan to retry Ms. Clancy on first-degree murder charges, lesser charges or at all. However, Judge William Sullivan indicated at a hearing earlier this month that he intends to choose a tentative start date for a second trial, and that he may do so at a 10 a.m. hearing on Monday in Plymouth Superior Court.
Jurors at Ms. Clancy’s first trial were unable to break their 11-1 deadlock after nearly 40 hours of deliberations, prompting the judge to declare a mistrial on Sept. 2. If prosecutors decide to reduce the charges to second-degree murder or manslaughter, Ms. Clancy could potentially avoid a second jury trial and have her fate decided by a judge instead.
Last week, Judge Sullivan dismissed several motions filed by Ms. Clancy’s lawyers, including one that argued for the complete dismissal of the charges. Her defense team has asserted that any retrial would constitute double jeopardy, arguing that the mistrial could have been avoided if the judge had investigated the conduct of the lone juror who voted to convict.
The defense team argued in its motion that a deeper inquiry might have uncovered grounds for dismissing that specific juror and replacing him with an alternate. In his ruling, Judge Sullivan rejected that argument, finding that such an inquiry would have been “impermissibly coercive” because there was no evidence that the juror had done anything wrong. The judge also dismissed a separate defense motion that had requested further investigation of the holdout juror.